Question 1

What is an applicant tracking system and do I need one?

Accepted Answer

An applicant tracking system centralises every job application in one place, tracks candidates through a configurable pipeline, records interview feedback and manages offer communications. You need one as soon as your hiring volume makes inbox-based recruitment unreliable — typically when you are running more than two or three concurrent roles or when multiple hiring managers need visibility into the same pipeline. Without one, candidates fall through the cracks and your process becomes inconsistent.

Question 2

What is the difference between an ATS and a recruitment CRM?

Accepted Answer

An ATS manages active applicants moving through a hiring process. A recruitment CRM manages longer-term candidate relationships — talent pools of people you want to hire in the future, alumni networks, passive candidates and repeat applicants. Some platforms combine both. If most of your hires come from inbound applications, an ATS is the right starting point. If you do significant outbound sourcing or build talent pipelines for future roles, you need CRM capability as well.

Question 3

How do I improve candidate experience with software?

Accepted Answer

Candidate experience is shaped by response time, communication clarity and the effort required from the candidate at each stage. Software helps by automating status updates at each stage change, sending calendar invites directly from the system rather than via email back-and-forth, and giving candidates a clear view of what the next steps are. The biggest improvements come from eliminating the black hole between application and first response — automated acknowledgement within minutes, not days.

Question 4

How should I structure an interview scorecard?

Accepted Answer

A useful scorecard has four to six competencies directly relevant to the role, each with a defined scale (typically one to five) and example behaviours at each level. Interviewers record evidence for each competency during the interview rather than scoring from memory afterwards. The total score should be directional, not decisive — use it to structure the debrief conversation, not to replace it. Avoid general personality ratings that introduce bias without predictive value.

Question 5

How do I keep hiring compliant with GDPR?

Accepted Answer

Under GDPR, you must have a lawful basis for processing candidate data, typically legitimate interest during the active recruitment process. Once a candidate is rejected or the role is filled, you must either delete their data or obtain explicit consent to retain it for a future opportunities pool. Set retention periods in your ATS — most platforms support automated deletion after a configurable number of days. Ensure candidates can request deletion of their data and that you can fulfil that request without manually searching multiple systems.

Question 6

What metrics should I track to evaluate hiring performance?

Accepted Answer

Track time-to-hire (offer accepted to start date), time-to-fill (role opened to offer accepted), sourcing channel conversion rate (applications to hires by source), offer acceptance rate and cost per hire. These five metrics reveal whether your bottleneck is sourcing volume, pipeline velocity, interview process length or offer competitiveness. Without them, hiring process improvements are based on anecdote rather than evidence.

Hiring marketplace

Malt

Connectd

Recruitee

CodeInterview

Upwork